Skip to main content

Get up close and personal on mentor-protegé relationships

Concordia study examines informal mentor-protegé relationships, while university offers formal opportunities
March 10, 2014
|
By Alyssa Tremblay


If Hollywood movies came true, bright-eyed graduates would start their entry-level jobs with an uplifting indie soundtrack and a world-wise mentor to help them navigate murky workplace waters.

The Concordia Mentor Program streamlines the process of connecting mentors and protégés. The Concordia Mentor Program streamlines the process of connecting mentors and protégés. | Photo credit: Concordia University

According to new research from Concordia University, University of St. Thomas and University of Houston, coveted mentor/protégé relationships don’t spring up naturally —  in fact, what occurs more often can be described as unrequited mentorship.

The study, co-authored by Devasheesh Bhave, an assistant professor in the Department of Management of Concordia’s John Molson School of Business, surveyed 376 people. “Neither potential protégés nor potential mentors were very accurate at identifying informal mentoring partners,” he reported.

While the majority of people surveyed could identify one person from their workplace they viewed as a mentor, this feeling was rarely mutual. Protégés were accurate in identifying a colleague as a mentor less than half of the time.

One potential reason, says Bhave, is that “the popular press frequently reminds them that mentoring is critical to career success., and this may motivate protégés to incorrectly consider that their relationship is a mentoring one.”

Mentoring options for students and alumni

Yet a great mentoring relationship is still achievable. One way is through university programs like the Concordia Mentor Program, one of several options offered by Concordia’s Advancement and Alumni Relations to foster interactions between students and graduates of the university.

“The Concordia Mentor Program is a formalized approach to the traditional mentor-mentee relationship,” says Jonathan Goldman, an alumni officer who oversees student programs.

Watch our video on mentoring programs offered through Backpack to Briefcase:

The Concordia Mentor Program streamlines the process of connecting mentors and protégés. Concordia alumni interested in mentoring who register are matched with students seeking guidance.

“Participants search for potential mentors by degree type, occupation, company name or geographic location. They can reach out to whomever they like,” says Goldman. “Mentors similarly respond to mentee requests, if they feel it’s a suitable match.”

All communication between mentors and mentees takes place on a private server and all personal information, including email addresses, remains confidential. Participants must also follow a code of conduct to make the mentoring experience successful.

“There is a nice life-cycle effect to the program. Mentees who graduate come back to serve as mentors,” says Goldman.

  • Interested in mentoring a Concordia student? Consult opportunities in our related links below or contact Jonathan Goldman, alumni officer, Student Programs, at jonathan.goldman@concordia.ca.


Back to top

© Concordia University