The surprising truth about obsessive-compulsive thinking
People who check whether their hands are clean or imagine their house might be on fire are not alone. New research from Concordia University and 15 other universities worldwide shows that 94 per cent of people experience unwanted, intrusive thoughts, images and/or impulses.
The international study, which was co-authored by Concordia psychology professor Adam Radomsky and published in the Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders, examined people on six continents.
Radomsky and his colleagues found that the thoughts, images and impulses symptomatic of obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) are widespread.
“This study shows that it’s not the unwanted, intrusive thoughts that are the problem — it’s what you make of those thoughts,” Radomsky says. “And that’s at the heart of our cognitive and behavioural interventions for helping people overcome OCD.”
This means therapists can focus on applying effective treatments that will work cross-culturally.
As Radomsky points out, "Confirming that these thoughts are extremely common helps us reassure patients who may think that they are very different from everybody else."
"For instance, most people who have an intrusive thought about jumping off a balcony or a metro platform would tell themselves that it’s a strange or silly thing to think, whereas a person with OCD may worry that the thought means they’re suicidal. OCD patients experience these thoughts more often and are more upset by them, but the thoughts themselves seem to be indistinguishable from those occurring in the general population.”
For researchers developing effective evidence-based mental health treatments, recognizing how widespread these intrusive thoughts are can also offer encouragement to use cognitive and behavioural therapies cross-culturally.
“We’re more similar than we are different,” says Radomsky. “People with OCD and related problems are very much like everyone else."
About the study
The researchers assessed 777 university students in 13 countries across six continents. In Canada, participants were from Montreal and Fredericton. Internationally, research was conducted in Argentina, Australia, France, Greece, Hong Kong, Iran, Israel, Italy, Sierra Leone, Spain, Turkey and the United States.
Participants were questioned about whether they had experienced at least one unwanted, intrusive thought in the three months prior. To ensure participants reported intrusions, researchers worked with them to distinguish between lingering worries, ruminations about previous events and unwanted intrusions. These can be a phrase (“Did I lock the front door?”), an image (a mental picture of the subject’s house on fire) or an urge (for instance, a desire to hurt someone). Contamination, aggression and doubt were among the many types of intrusive thoughts reported by participants.
Partners in research
This work was supported in part by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC).
Co-authors of this study were Gillian Alcolado, a doctoral student at Concordia University; Jon Abramowitz of the University of Chapel Hill in North Carolina; Pino Alonso of the University of Makeni in Sierra Leone; Amparo Belloch of the University of Valencia in Spain; Martine Bouvard of the Université de Savoie in France; David A. Clark of the University of New Brunswick; Meredith Coles of Binghamton University in New York; Guy Doron of the Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya in Israel; Hector Fernández-Álvarez of the Aigle Foundation in Argentina; Gemma Garcia-Soriano of the University of Valencia in Spain; Marta Ghisi of the University of Padova in Italy; Beatriz Gomen at the Aigle Foundation in Argentina; Mujgan Inozu of Abant Izzet Baysal University in Turkey; Richard Moulding of Deakin University in Australia; Giti Shams of the Tehran University of Medical Science in Iran; Claudio Sica of the University of Firenze in Italy; Gregoris Simos of the University of Macedonia in Greece; and Wing Wong of the Chinese University of Hong Kong.