As the school year winds down, many teenagers are starting summer jobs to earn money and gain experience. Businesses benefit from the seasonal influx of young workers across industries such as hospitality, construction, landscaping and retail.
Family businesses will also see many of their own return to the fold. Keeping work close to home can seem like the best way to keep teenagers safe. Parents know their children, and children know the family business.
Yet our recent research with Mariyam Rabbani and Anna Merrifield suggests that family employment does not automatically make work safer. In some cases, working for a parent may make safety conversations less frequent and may be linked to a greater risk of injury.
Early work experiences teach young people what is “normal” on the job, including whether it’s acceptable to refuse unsafe tasks or speak up when something feels wrong. Young workers are also already vulnerable because they are still learning tasks, hazards, expectations and workplace norms.
Research from Ontario’s Workplace Safety Insurance Board shows workers under 25 are four times more likely to be injured in their first month on the job than at any other time.
When family and work overlap
Our study examined 2,275 employed young workers in Ontario, aged 14 to 18. The data came from a larger young worker safety research program led by Sean Tucker, a human resource management professor at the University of Regina.
We were interested in whether working with or for a parent changes how young people communicate about safety.
We separated participants into four groups: those who did not work for or with a parent; those who worked for a parent’s business but not directly alongside them; those who worked alongside a parent but not in a parent-owned business; and those who both worked for and with a parent. About one in seven young workers in our sample had some form of parent-linked employment.
We expected family involvement to help because it could provide more opportunities for parents to talk about safety and reduce the likelihood of work injuries.
That was not what we found.
Young people who worked for a parent reported less frequent safety communication than those with no parent-linked arrangement. Those who worked for a parent, or both for and with a parent, were more likely to report a lost-time injury.
The study does not prove that family jobs cause injuries. We did not have detailed information about industry, hazards or training quality. But the results challenge the assumption that family closeness automatically creates safer work.