Plan your assessment strategy
Learn to recognize the difference between formative and summative assessment and how using an alignment strategy helps ensure that your assignments are planned to gauge the course’s learning outcomes.
Planning assessments
Planning and aligning your assessments with your learning outcomes is central to effective assessment design and is key to good course design. In this way, you ensure that your assessment tasks match and measure the most essential knowledge, skills, and values you intend for your students to develop in your course.
When designing or redesigning a course, after you have determined the desired learning outcomes, the next step is to plan the assessments that will allow you to gauge whether students are meeting the planned learning outcomes. A good first step is to determine the formative and summative assessments for a given course. The next step is to determine the course alignment.
Types of assessment
Assessments are generally categorized into two main types (Black et al., 1998):
Formative assessment is ongoing throughout the semester, allows you to monitor students’ progress in learning and provide feedback so students can identify gaps between your expectations and their learning. By encouraging students to monitor their learning based on the feedback they receive, this kind of assessment gives students more agency around their learning and can help them better achieve the learning outcomes. Formative assessment usually has low stakes, which means it has little or no point value in a student’s grade. Focusing on improving student learning early on and throughout the semester can also help ensure that students are adequately prepared for summative assessments. It can be helpful to think of formative assessment as assessment for learning.
Examples include:
- An outline or annotated bibliography in advance of a paper
- Discussion forum in Moodle
- Informal feedback on projects
- Minute papers
- Reading responses
- Self-reflection questions or activities
- Student response systems for assessing prior knowledge or understanding (e.g., pre-course surveys on Moodle, ungraded in-class polling or quizzes)
- Take home practice problems with provided answer keys
Summative assessment takes place at designated times in the semester to measure competence and usually contributes with higher stakes to a student’s grade. In this type of assessment, students’ learning is measured at the end of a unit or course against a predetermined standard. It can be helpful to think of summative assessment as assessment of learning.
Examples include:
- Alternatives to exams or term papers (e.g., multimedia projects, podcasts, two-stage exams, etc.)
- Final projects or papers
- Midterm exams
Course alignment
In an aligned course, each learning outcome has at least one (but preferably more) ways of assessing student learning. This alignment process also helps focus the design of assessments so that you are measuring exactly what you intend to measure and that there are no unnecessary assessment tasks.
The example below comes from a Business Information Technologies Course where students have to explore the role of information technology in business organizations. This example demonstrates how each learning outcome is assessed with each of the course assignments and final exam.
Note that, as a best practice, each learning outcome should be evaluated a minimum of two times in a course. In this example, we can see that each assessment evaluates at least one course outcome. Depending on how many learning outcomes your course has and how specific they are, each assessment can evaluate a single outcome or multiple outcomes, as you see fit.
Example of course alignment
A single assignment can be used to assess multiple learning outcomes.
All learning outcomes are assessed with a final exam. The other assignments are aligned with one or more of the course's learning outcomes.
Source: Adapted from COMM 226 Business Technology Management (Supply Chain and Business Technology Department, Concordia University)
Learning outcome | Assignment |
---|---|
Describe the main concepts of information systems and related concepts |
|
Describe the relationship between information systems and competitive advantage |
|
Identify the major trends in IS technologies such as SCRM, SCM, and ERP and their use to improve business efficiency, increase profits and support other business functions |
|
Identify how to use E-commerce and E-business to create new or improve existing business |
|
Demonstrate how systems can enhance business decision-making and help create business partnerships |
|
Describe how organizations analyze, develop, acquire and implement information systems |
|
Discuss issues related to computer crime and security, and information systems ethics |
|
All learning outcomes |
|
Reference
Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and Classroom Learning. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 5(1), 7–74. https://doi.org/10.1080/0969595980050102