Skip to main content
Thesis defences

PhD Oral Exam - Alexandre Joyce, Individualized Program

A Proposal for a Design Approach to more Sustainable Business Models: Tools, process and outcomes to imagine the future of organizations


Date & time
Tuesday, June 7, 2016
10 a.m. – 1 p.m.
Cost

This event is free

Organization

School of Graduate Studies

Contact

Sharon Carey
514-848-2424, ext. 3802

Where

Henry F. Hall Building
1455 De Maisonneuve W.
Room H - 1001.01

Wheel chair accessible

Yes

When studying for a doctoral degree (PhD), candidates submit a thesis that provides a critical review of the current state of knowledge of the thesis subject as well as the student’s own contributions to the subject. The distinguishing criterion of doctoral graduate research is a significant and original contribution to knowledge.

Once accepted, the candidate presents the thesis orally. This oral exam is open to the public.

Abstract

Stories of organizations transforming their business model is nothing new. At some point in time, any organization, big or small, reaches a crossroad where strategic thinking points towards reinvention. However, we argue that most business model changes are not specifically designed for environmental or social benefits but predominantly economic gains.

From our literature review, we determine that most research in the nascent field of sustainable business models is concerned with the ends of integrating a sustainability dimension to business models, however there is little empirical research on the means towards that transformation. Our research endeavour is constructivist and multidisciplinary at the convergence of design, management and sustainability. Our interest lies in the creative aspect of business model innovation when an organization conceptualizes future business models for sustainability. At that phase, we perceive a need for a structured design approach to more sustainable business models. Our research question is 'What could constitute a design approach to envisioning sustainable business models?' We define a sustainable business model as the rationale of how a business creates, delivers and captures economic, environmental and social value. Our goal is to lay the foundations for the emerging practice of designing sustainable business models. We create a conceptual framework where we propose three inherent elements of a design approach: design tools, design process and design outcomes. We justify each element of a design approach to more sustainable business models by reporting from our empirical fieldwork. By following an action based research methodology, we prepared 19 workshops with over 400 participants such as 13 manufacturing companies to develop and validate our design approach. During this fieldwork, we created two design tools. The triple layered business model canvas tool that was born from a triple bottom line perspective expanding on the popular business model canvas. Twenty four business model pattern cards were also created to enhance the creativity of participants. For the design process element, we combined co-creation and design thinking processes to build on the strengths of each other and answer for their weaknesses. Our third element focused on design outcomes and we generated 5 cases which demonstrated the coherence of our design approach at three organizational levels: strategic, tactical and operational.

In this dissertation, we join all three elements of a design approach together to envision more sustainable business models. From this we learn how the design tools support a structure, the design process builds on experience and the design outcomes offer direction towards. We then conclude on how our design approach relates to three types of practitioners. First, we recognize the link between our design approach with the creativity and instinctual qualities of designers. Second, managers and entrepreneurs are well served by our design approach because their participation contributes to establishing a problem context before inviting them into an exploration space where they can embrace how the elements of a design approach favours learning. Lastly, because our design approach is applied at a system level of a business model, sustainability experts are empowered to conceive radical improvements with new forms of analysis concerning the sustainability of organization as a whole. That is why we see our design approach as the means to initiate change in organizations by providing a positive vision of what a sustainable business model can be. In the end, we contribute to research on business models for sustainability by exposing how a design approach can serve organizations insupporting the process, tools, and outcomes of their transformations.

This dissertation is structured in the following manner. The first chapter begins by establishing the context for sustainable business models. We also point out some fields and authors that call for this new practice of sustainable business model design. In the second chapter, we take a step back to review the literature for a better understanding of how the management and design fields are converging. The gap we seek to study is how a design approach can constitute the means to more sustainable business models. We then define a design approach and propose a conceptual framework by combining three elements: design tools, design process and design outcomes. The third chapter is dedicated to the action research methods by which we construct a design approach to sustainable business models. The artifacts description and evaluation chapter showcases all the data we created concerning each of the three elements of a design approach. The fifth chapter discusses the main findings from our empirical fieldwork and the participant feedback with respect to the value of the three elements to a design approach. We also further discuss our main contributions and outlining a few limits and future research opportunities. In the conclusion, we address how our design approach is relevant to the research fields we explored and its practitioners. We then comment on how this practice of designing sustainable business models will influence the next century's paradigm.


Back to top

© Concordia University